Plum Ice Cream

Plum ice cream was the first flavor I ever tasted that made me believe dessert could tell a story.

I was seven. The summer sun had turned Georgia’s red clay roads to dust, and my aunt’s kitchen smelled like vanilla extract and hot peaches. But it was the plums that caught my eye—deep purple, soft as secrets, piled in a chipped porcelain bowl. We didn’t have much, but we had those plums and an old hand-crank ice cream maker. I still remember turning that crank until my arms ached, my grandmother humming low blues through the screen door.

When I finally took a bite—cold, tangy, creamy—I felt like I’d just tasted something sacred.

This recipe is a revival of that moment: soulful, rich, and easy enough to make on a lazy Sunday. Whether you’re craving something nostalgic or just tired of vanilla pretending to be exotic, this plum ice cream will reset your summer palate.

Part 1: The Beauty of Plum Ice Cream

What flavour is purple ice cream?

Purple ice cream isn’t just a color—it’s a mood. A deep, velvety kind of sweet that feels like slow jazz on a warm night. With plum ice cream, that hue comes from the skin of ripe plums—usually red, black, or Japanese varieties. And the flavor? Oh, honey.

It’s a gentle tango between tart and floral. Imagine biting into a sun-warmed plum straight from the tree, the juice running down your wrist. Now, imagine that captured in a cloud of cream. There’s nothing artificial here—just real fruit doing what it does best.

Some compare it to grape or cherry, but that’s like comparing a love letter to a text message. Plums have depth. Layers. A perfume that lingers.

The flavor is naturally enhanced by the dairy, which smooths out the sharper notes. Add a touch of honey or brown sugar, and you’ve got something elegant but grounded—like a Southern belle in a Paris café.

Japanese plum ice cream: a bold twist

Now if you’ve ever tasted ume—those salty-sour Japanese pickled plums—you know they’re not shy. Japanese plum ice cream leans into that bold contrast, often pairing the fruit with creamy bases to tame the tang.

I’ve made a version with white miso and shiso leaves that blew my dinner guests’ minds. But for today’s recipe, we’re going more classic: using roasted black or red plums that caramelize in the oven and whisper their secrets into every bite.

Still, I always say—if your pantry’s feeling adventurous, a splash of yuzu or a pinch of shichimi togarashi could take your next batch to Tokyo and back.

Part 2: Building Flavor from the Fruit Up

Roasted plum ice cream: why it matters

Raw plums are pretty. Roasted plums are poetry.

I roast mine with a drizzle of honey, a touch of cinnamon, and the tiniest splash of balsamic vinegar. The result? Plums that taste like jam and smell like a warm orchard breeze.

Roasting does three magical things:

1. It intensifies sweetness without needing too much sugar.
2. It deepens the color—hello, dreamy purple swirl.
3. It softens the fruit, making it blend smoother into your base.

When I first served this at a backyard summer solstice supper, folks thought I’d used some exotic imported ingredient. Nope. Just regular ol’ plums from the farmer’s market, roasted until they whispered back.

Pro Tip: Save the syrupy juices left on the roasting tray. Stir them into the base or drizzle over the final scoops for an extra flavor hit.

Plum ice cream without ice cream machine

I’ve worked in Michelin-starred kitchens with PacoJets and blast freezers. But let me tell you—some of my best ice cream moments happened without fancy gear.

If you don’t have an ice cream machine, don’t you dare give up.

Here’s the no-churn magic formula:

• Sweetened condensed milk brings body and silkiness.
• Heavy cream, whipped to soft peaks adds volume and that “airiness” you crave.
• Roasted plum puree folded in makes it rich and fruity.

Pour this velvet mix into a loaf pan, cover it with foil, and freeze for at least 6 hours. That’s it.

When my neighbor Miss Lena tasted this version, she licked the spoon, raised her brows, and whispered, “Now Tiffany, you didn’t buy this at the store?” I just winked and handed her a second scoop.

If you’re loving this no-churn vibe, don’t miss my other freezer faves—these chocolate chocolate chip ice cream bars are fudgy, nostalgic, and built for summer cravings. No machine, just magic.

Part 3: Pairings & Creative Twists

What flavours go well with plums?

Plums are flexible, like a jazz melody that adapts to the moment. Depending on their ripeness and variety, they play well with both bright and bold ingredients.

Here are my favorite pairings:

• Warm spices: Cinnamon, cardamom, and star anise highlight plum’s earthy undertones. Add a whisper of these to your roasted fruit or base mix.
• Citrus: Lemon zest wakes everything up, while orange pairs with plum like gospel harmonies on a Sunday morning.
• Honey & ginger: Honey softens tartness. Ginger adds a slow, warming kick. (Try both together—it’s a revelation.)
• Herbs: Basil for brightness. Thyme for depth. Mint for a garden-fresh twist.

And if you want to dress it up? Serve your plums ice cream with a drizzle of balsamic reduction or alongside buttery shortbread cookies for a plate worthy of applause.

Creative plum ice cream recipes to try next

Once you’ve mastered the classic, here’s how to riff like a chef:

• Plum & Black Pepper: A bold grown-up version. The heat sneaks in at the end—just enough to keep things interesting.
• Roasted Plum & Almond Crunch: Fold in chopped toasted almonds before freezing. The texture? Unreal.
• Plum + Vanilla Bean Swirl: Simmer vanilla bean in the cream base for a floral-cream flavor that wraps around the fruit like a warm hug.

Want to take it on the go? Freeze a slab and slice your plum ice cream into sandwiches just like these strawberry ice cream sandwiches. It’s a playful, portable twist kids and grown-ups love.

I even once folded plum ice cream into a homemade brioche bun, topped it with crushed pistachios, and called it a Southern-Italian “ice cream sandwich.” The table went silent… then empty. Fast.

Tools You’ll Need

• Roasting pan
• Blender or food processor
• Loaf pan
• Mixing bowls
• Silicone spatula
• Ice cream scoop
• Airtight freezer container

Part 4: Nutrition Notes & FAQs

Let’s talk truth: plums ice cream isn’t a “health food” by any strict definition. But when you make it from scratch—with real fruit, fewer additives, and the option to control your sweeteners—you’re already doing better than 90% of the frozen aisle.

Nutrition Tip:

Use coconut cream instead of dairy and maple syrup instead of condensed milk for a dairy-free and refined sugar-free version that still scoops like a dream. The plums do a lot of the sweet talking.

And now, to answer what y’all have been asking…

Can you make plum ice cream?

Absolutely. Whether you’ve got an ice cream machine or just a whisk and a freezer, plum ice cream is totally doable at home. The real secret? Starting with ripe, flavorful plums and not skimping on the love.

What flavour is purple ice cream?

Purple usually means plum, ube (purple yam), or grape. But plum is the most nuanced—tart, sweet, slightly floral, and softly tangy. It’s like tasting a late summer afternoon.

What’s the healthiest ice cream you can eat?

The healthiest one is the one you make. When you choose your ingredients—like using Greek yogurt, oat milk, or even aquafaba—you control the sugar, fat, and flavor. My dairy-free plum ice cream with honey and roasted fruit? Pretty darn saintly.

What flavours go well with plums?

Short answer: a whole lot! Ginger, honey, vanilla, citrus, almond, and cardamom all elevate the natural depth of plum. Even black pepper or rosemary, if you’re feeling bold.

Conclusion: A Scoop of Summer, A Spoonful of Soul

Making plum ice cream is more than a kitchen project—it’s a way to bottle a season. A way to slow down and say: this moment matters. Whether you’re sharing it on the porch with your kids, packing it into picnic jars, or eating it straight from the pan at midnight (I’ve been there), this is ice cream that speaks.

And don’t let perfection stop you. You don’t need fancy tools or chef-level skills. Just some juicy plums, a little fire (oven or heart), and a love for what food can do: bring joy, stir memories, and remind us how sweet life can be.

And if you’re craving that toasted campfire flavor next? My s’mores ice cream bars layer all the gooey nostalgia into one dreamy bite.

Want more behind-the-scenes bites and real-time recipes?
Come hang out with me on Facebook and Pinterest—I’d love to see your creations!

Print